As the summer wanes, I have gotten a surprising number of questions about pruning. My first thought is why. My advice is don’t.
Any pruning cut is a wound that will invite insects, disease and dieback. The goal is to get a quick heal from growth when you prune. That would suggest that pruning when the tree or shrub is heading into dormancy is the worst time to get out the shears.
Also, pruning often stimulates additional growth. Rapid growth now, from pruning or fertilizer applications, will be slow to go dormant and be much more vulnerable to damage in our normal winter.
Finally, if you are dealing with a spring blooming shrub, you will almost certainly be removing flower buds, which form in mid summer for the next year.
Granted all plants do not have equal hardiness. Apple trees have tolerances approaching minus 35 degrees. They don’t care when you prune them. Peaches, on the other hand, occasionally lose buds in our coldest winters as well as being more susceptible to disease.
Shrubs rated only to our zone 6 will occasionally get into trouble without our help. Butterfly bushes quickly come to mind. Prune them now; add in a cold, windy winter and almost certainly you will be replacing them next year.
We also are pushing the limits with crape myrtle. That doesn’t say we can’t grow them successfully. It’s just that they suffer a bit of winter damage most years. Prune them now and you will get even more damage.
Several days ago I was quizzed about training a crape myrtle into a tree form. That’s common in the south, but I haven’t seen successful examples much farther north than southern Delaware.
As I think about what I am writing (sometimes I do that), I am struggling to come up with a go ahead to whack fall blooming shrubs. The best I can come up with would be the twig dogwoods. They are grown for their twig color and not their bloom, so maybe I should admit that I cant think of any.
My guess is that those of you thinking about pruning now have only four of the seven letters correct. That’s the first one and the last three. Transform that into planting and I would agree you have hit on a wonderful idea.
If you are planting, maybe the dialog on pruning above can spawn a good idea. If you are planting something winter tender, get moving or wait for spring. If it’s of average toughness you have maybe two months. The real tough ones won’t care as long as the ground isn’t frozen.
There are times to prune and times to plant. Successful gardeners put the rhythm of the plants ahead of their schedules.