Recently I had some outpatient eye surgery. As part of the pre-op I was told to get clearance from my family doctor. After a quick scan of the vital signs, a few well-placed pokes and a few mumbles about the waste of medical dollars he filled out the necessary paperwork.
His gripe is that the medical journals more than five years ago reported that the physical stress of my surgery was so small that he was wasting his time and my money. Yet he reported you would not find a surgeon who would do this work without a similar checkup.
I chuckled because I see almost universal disbelief about my answer when people ask how to prepare a hole for planting. The answer is that almost, if not always, the best approach is to do nothing. Dig the hole, set the plant in, water it and cover it. Go on to the next plant or put your tools away.
Research in 1979 at the University of Oklahoma proved that amending the hole was worse than just planting. Prior to that, it was common practice to enhance the hole with peat moss or like material and even throw in a little fertilizer to boot.
What the research showed was that the plant was so happy in its special hole that its roots refused to grow beyond the magic circle. It was the equivalent of leaving the plant in the plastic pot when planting. Yes, that was thirty years ago and yet there are few converts.
I first heard about the research about ten years ago in a class at Longwood Gardens. Before that, I believed the conventional wisdom that the hole needed improvement.
The 1979 research has been repeated ad infinim at university after university, in all kinds of soil and with all kinds of amendments. The results remain the same. The untreated planting is best although they have uncovered a few processes that may give equal results. It's time to be lazy and put this one to rest.
The last study I read claimed that if we dug a star shaped hole, the roots would grow into the star's points quickly accelerating the root growth in general. Wow, does anybody know how many points a star has?
Enough sarcasm. We can agree that an oversized hole is better that one that just barely accommodates the roots. We can agree if you must amend the soil it is ok to do the whole area with the necessary tillage to provide the transplant with a uniform soil mixture.
Other than that, save your time, energy and money. Put your improvement efforts into the corn or potato patch. Perennials, shrubs, trees, most annuals and most vegetables will be happier in what you have, rather than in what you could make.